As Reid Pushes Partisan Bailout Bill For 3rd Time In As Many Days,
DNC Ad Misleads On Who’s Really In The Pocket Of Wall Street Fat Cats
Claim
DNC Ad Claims That Their Bill Would “Protect Consumers” And “Prevent Future Bailouts.” “Wall Street’s risky bets nearly sank our economy. But when it came to Wall Street reform that would protect consumers and prevent future bailouts every Senate Republican voted ‘no.’” (DNC, “Risky Business,” TV Ad, 4/28/10)
Facts
But For Third Time In Three Days, Sen. Harry Reid (D-NV) Tried To Move Forward With Obama-Dodd Bill That Federal Trade Commission Says Could Mean “Less Protection For Consumers, And Fewer ‘Cops On The Beat.’” “The Federal Trade Commission … writes to express its strong and unanimous concerns with certain provisions in the ‘Restoring American Financial Stability Act of 2010,’ which was recently reported by the senate banking committee … We fear that the overall result could be less protection for consumers, and fewer ‘cops on the beat.’” (S. 3127, Roll Call Vote #127, Reconsideration Of Cloture Vote On The Motion To Proceed, Rejected 56-42 (60 Votes Needed), R: 0-40, D: 54-2, I: 2-0, 4/27/10; Federal Trade Commission, Letter To Sen. Hutchison, 4/16/10)
National Journal Says “Under The Dodd Plan, Although The Senator Denies It, Many Big Financial Firms Would Indeed Be Declared Too Big To Fail.” (Clive Crook, “Dodd Misses The Point Of Financial Reform,” The National Journal, 3/20/10)
- Obama-Dodd Bill Creates $50 Billion Permanent Bailout Fund. (Page 277, S. 3217, Restoring American Financial Stability Act Of 2010, Introduced 4/15/10)
- Obama-Dodd Bill Could Lead To More Taxpayer-Funded Bailouts By Expanding Federal Reserve’s Power To Establish “Policies And Procedures Governing Emergency Lending.” (Page 1365, S. 3217, Restoring American Financial Stability Act Of 2010, Introduced 4/15/10)
- Obama-Dodd Bill Could Make Taxpayer-Funded Bailouts Even More Expensive By Allowing FDIC To Make “Additional Payments” To Firms That Backed Failed Financial Companies. (Page 245, S. 3217, Restoring American Financial Stability Act Of 2010, Introduced 4/15/10)
- Obama-Dodd Bill Uses Taxpayer Dollars To Guarantee Debt Of Banks And Bank Holding Companies Through The Power Of The Federal Reserve And FDIC. (Page 1379, S. 3217, Restoring American Financial Stability Act Of 2010, Introduced 4/15/10)
- Obama-Dodd Bill Could Institutionalize Bailouts By Allowing A New Financial Oversight Council To Determine Which Companies Are “Too Big To Fail.” (Page 35, S. 3217, Restoring American Financial Stability Act Of 2010, Introduced 4/15/10)
Claim
DNC Ad Claims Republicans Blocked Financial Reform. “Republicans voted to block reform after a fundraiser with Wall Street lobbyists.” (DNC, “Risky Business,” TV Ad, 4/28/10)
Facts
But Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA) Says Republican Concerns About Obama-Dodd Bill “Are Legitimate”And That “Parts” Of The Bill “Need To Be Tightened.” “Sen. Mark Warner, the Virginia Democrat who has been closely involved in negotiations, said that concerns being raised by republicans about potential bailouts of large financial institutions are legitimate … ‘There are parts that need to be tightened,’ Warner said, referring to the bill in the same manner as Sen. Richard Shelby, Alabama Republican and ranking member on the Senate Banking Committee.” (Jon Ward, “Obama Offers Simple Narrative Of GOP Obstruction, But Key Lawmakers Tell Another Story,” The Daily Caller, 4/27/10)
Reid’s Failed Cloture Votes “Is Exactly What [Democrat] Political Operatives Wanted” So That They Can Delay Getting A Bill Done. “Democrats lost the financial reform vote monday evening - which is exactly what their political operatives wanted … And finally, it allows the majority party to string out debate for a few more days on a bill…” (Martin Kaddy II, “Winning While Losing,” Politico’s “The Huddle,” 4/27/10)
- By Holding Votes, Reid “Has Decided To Play A Game Of Political Chicken” On Financial Reform In Order To “Make It A Prominent Issue In The Mid-Term Elections.” “Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) has decided to play a game of political chicken with Senate Republicans, daring them to kill a Wall Street reform bill. Reid said he plans to move ahead with immediate consideration of the financial re gulatory reform bill … Reid has shown a willingness to force Republicans to vote on and kill the legislation. If the bill derails, Democrats say they will make it a prominent issue in the mid-term elections.” (Alexander Bolton, “Reid Plays Chicken On Wall Street Reform,” The Hill, 4/20/10)
And It Was Obama Who Scuttled Bipartisan Negotiations Three Times To Use Financial Regulation Debate As Political Weapon. “[S]ome Democrats believe continued action after health care reform will show real momentum for their agenda. But others argue that the White House would be better off – politically, anyway – if Democrats could hit the campaign trail in the fall and blame … Republicans for blocking the reform bill.” (Manu Raju and Eamon Javers, “Dems Bristle At Reform Deadline,” Politico, 4/5/10)
- FEBRUARY: White House Pulled Sen. Chris Dodd (D-CT) Away From Negotiation With Sen. Richard Shelby (R-AL). “Just six days earlier, Dodd had said he hit an impasse with Senator Richard Shelby, the committee’s top Republican, in talks that have dragged on for more than a year over tightening oversight of banks and capital markets … Gregg said he believes Dodd and Shelby had an agreement on consumer protection before talks broke off. ‘If the white house hadn’t sort of pulled back the Democratic membership on that issue, we could all go forward in a bipartisan way.’” (Kevin Drawbaugh, “GOP’s Gregg Sees Progress On Financial Regulation,” Reuters, 2/12/10)
- MARCH: White House Pressured Dodd To Abandon Bipartisan Negotiations With Sen. Bob Corker (R-TN). “Dodd announced Thursday he would schedule a committee markup the week of March 22 even though he and Sen. Bob Corker (R-Tenn.) had not struck a final deal… Corker said negotiations were on ‘the 5-yard line’ and blamed politics … for complicating the talks … ‘There is no question that White House politics and healthcare have kept us from getting to the goal line,’ …” (Silla Brush, “Banking Chairman Dodd To Go It Alone On Financial Overhaul,” The Hill, 3/11/10)
- APRIL: Sens. Blanche Lincoln (D-AR) And Saxby Chambliss (R-GA) Were Nearing Bipartisan Deal On Derivatives Until “White House Raised Objections To A Potential Compromise.” “White House officials have raised objections to a potential compromise between Democrats and Republicans on the Senate Agriculture Committee regarding rules governing derivatives trading … The pressure from the White House and Treasury Department could complicate the broader congressional effort to rework financial regulation, as it could derail a bipartisan deal. … The Senate Agriculture Committee proposal, spearheaded by panel chairman Blanche Lincoln and Saxby Chambliss was seen by many as one of the few parts of the bill that could attract bipartisan support.” (Damian Paletta, “Hurdle Emerges To Financial Revamp,” The Wall Street Journal, 4/13/10)
Claim
DNC Ad Claims Republicans Did Nothing To Rein In Wall Street. “Republicans stood by as Wall Street ran wild… .” (DNC, “Risky Business,” TV Ad, 4/28/10)
Facts
Clinton Signed Repeal Of Glass-Steagall Act That Allowed Banks To “Run Into Trouble,” Leading To Their Bailouts. “But 10 years later, the end of Glass-Steagall has been blamed by some for many of the problems that led to last fall’s financial crisis … the huge banks born out of the revocation of Glass-Steagall, especially Citigroup, and the insurance companies that were allowed to deal in securities, like the American International Group, would not have run into trouble had the law still been in place …” (Cyrus Sanati, “10 Years Later, Looking At Repeal Of Glass-Steagall,” The New York Times, 11/12/09)
- And President Clinton Regrets Taking Advice Of Former Treasury Secretaries Robert Rubin And Larry Summers For His Failure To Regulate The Derivatives Market. “Former President Bill Clinton said his Treasury Secretaries Robert Rubin and Lawrence Summers were wrong in the advice they gave him about regulating derivatives when he was in office. ‘I think they were wrong and I think I was wrong to take’ their advice, Clinton said in an interview on ABC’s ‘This Week’ program broadcast yesterday.” (Joshua Zumbrun, “Clinton Calls Advice He Received On Derivatives ‘Wrong’” Bloomberg, 4/19/10)
President Clinton Says That Blame For Crisis Rests With Democrats And His Administration For Resisting GOP Efforts To Reform Fannie And Freddie. ”I think the responsibility that the Democrats have may rest more in resisting any efforts by Republicans in the Congress, or by me when I was President, to put some standards and tighten up a little on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.” (Seth Colter Walls, “McCain Ad Uses President Clinton To Bash Democrats,” The Huffington Post, 10/31/08)
- Senate Republicans’ Plan Directly Addresses Two Key Areas Behind The Subprime Crisis That Democrats Have Ignored: Fannie and Freddie, And Mortgage Loan Underwriting. “In addition, the Republican proposal advances ideas in two areas — loan underwriting standards and the future of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the housing finance entities now under government control — that are not directly addressed in the Democratic bill.” (Sewell Chan, “Republicans Offer Alternative Financial Overhaul,” The New York Times “The Caucus” Blog, 4/27/10)
Claim
DNC Ad Claims Republicans “Are Standing With The Big Banks Again,” Siding “With Wall Street Over Main Street.” “[N]ow they are standing with the big banks again. Tell Republicans if they stand with Wall Street over Main Street again, you won’t be siding with them.” (DNC, “Risky Business,” TV Ad, 4/28/10)
Facts
But Rep. Brad Sherman (D-CA) Says Obama-Dodd Bill Has “Unlimited Executive Bailout Authority,” “Something Wall Street Desperately Wants.” “But there are serious problems with the Dodd bill. The Dodd bill has unlimited executive bailout authority. That’s something Wall Street desperately wants but doesn’t dare ask for. The bill contains permanent, unlimited bailout authority.” (Politico’s “Health Care Arena,” 4/19/10)
- That’s Why Goldman Sachs CEO, Llyod Blankfein, Says That He Supports The Dodd Bill And Agrees The “Biggest Beneficiaries Of Reform Will Be Wall Street Itself.” “I’m generally supportive. . . . [O]n the whole, financial reform is, absolutely is essential and I will say that last week, in New York, I listened to a speech by Barack Obama at Wall Street, and one of the points he made resonated with me because I’d said it myself. He said that the biggest beneficiaries of reform will be Wall Street itself.” (Homeland Security & Gov ernment Affairs, Permanent Subcommittee On Investigations, U.S. Senate, Hearing, 4/27/10)
- And Citigroup CEO, Vickram Pandit, Endorses Obama-Dodd Bill. “I was gratified to hear you speak about these principles as the foundation of regulatory reform and you can count on me and the entire Citi organization to support them.” (Vickram S. Pandit, Letter To President Barack Obama, 4/23/10)
And It’s Democrats Who Have Been Siding With Wall Street By Accepting At Least $7,125,624 From Goldman Sachs Since The 2006 Election Cycle. (Center for Responsive Politics, OpenSecrets.org, Accessed 4/16/10)
- In 2008 Election Cycle, President Obama Was The Largest Recipient Of Donations From JP Morgan, Goldman Sachs, Citi Group, AIG, Morgan Stanley And Bank Of America, Raking In Over $3,456,000. (Center for Responsive Politics, OpenSecrets.org, Accessed 4/16/10)
- Obama Received At Least $996,595 From Goldman Sachs During The 2008 Election. (Center for Responsive Politics, opensecrets.org, Accessed 4/20/10)
- DNC Has Accepted At Least $3,886,763 From The Finance Industry This Election Cycle. (Center for Responsive Politics, OpenSecrets.org, Accessed 4/16/10)
- DSCC Has Accepted At Least $3,907,970 From The Finance Industry This Election Cycle. (Center for Responsive Politics, OpenSecrets.org, Accessed 4/16/10)
Obama-Dodd Bill Hurts Main Street With Local Auto Dealers Saying It Goes After “The Wrong People” And Would “Drive Up The Cost Of Auto Financing.” “The dealers say the measure would drive up the cost of auto financing because it would require hiring more people to follow federal regulations. They say it also could limit the types of financial products they offer. ‘It’s dangerous and it’s aiming at the wrong people,’ said Ed Tonkin, chairman of the National Automobile Dealers Association. ‘It’s using a sledgehammer to go after a gnat, and we’re not that gnat.’” (Damian Paletta and Victoria McGranae, “Car Dealers Seek Exemption,” The Wall Street Journal, 4/28/10)
PDF Format
A Product Of The RNC Research Department
Paid for by the Republican National Committee.
310 First Street SE, Washington, D.C. 20003 -
(202) 863-8500 - www.gop.com
Not authorized by any candidate or candidate’s committee.